G.I. JOE #38
Judgments

Cover Date: August, 1985

Script: Larry Hama
Pencils: Rod Whigham
Inks: Andy Mushynsky

Lettering: Rick Parker
Colors: George Roussos
Editor: Denny O'Neil
Editor-in-Chief: Jim Shooter


Summary (by Rod Hannah):  Deep under suburban Springfield in Cobra headquarters, Billy's inquest is being held. Present are Storm Shadow, Zartan, Baroness, Major Bludd, Wild-Weasel and Firefly, while Destro leads the inquiry. Billy claims there were no accomplices and he did it all himself, but Destro contends otherwise. "Billy had help. Adult help. Someone who knew the program for the rally, knew Cobra procedure, knew exotic weaponry... and had  something to gain. Those are parameters that fit most of the tribunal assembled here!" Major Bludd whispers to the Baroness that if Billy talks, they're done for.

Meanwhile in the PX snackbar at Fort Wadsworth, Ripcord asks Gung-Ho how a guy is supposed to have a normal
relationship with a girl when he's a member of a top secret outfit that isn't even supposed to exist? Gung-Ho tells him he'll find a way to make it work, but Ripcord wonders whether he is really cut out to be a G.I. Joe. Stalker and Roadblock enter and tell Ripcord and Gung-Ho they have a new mission. Duke briefs them, explaining that a group of Americans went to Sierra Gordo in the hopes of arbitrating peace -- all but one were shot on sight. Now the Joes have to extract the surviving peace-maker -- Dr. Adele Burkhart.

Back in Springfield, Zartan explains there is a simple solution to finding out the co-conspirators -- using the late Dr. Venom's brainwave scanner. Cobra Commander agrees and has Billy taken to the device. High above Sierra Gordo in a C-130 transport plane, Stalker, Gung-Ho, Ripcord and Roadblock prepare for a HALO jump. Ripcord tells Stalker that he
hears Burkhart is against everything they are fighting for. Stalker explains that they are fighting for is Dr. Burkhart's right, and every other American's right to believe in whatever they want to. "Personally, I think Dr. Burkhart is an uppity, self-centered, pretentious old windbag and if I even suspected for one second that our saving her would alter her convictions one iota... I'd lose every shred of respect I have for her!"

In the Brainwave Scanner room of Cobra HQ, Billy's blocks out the co-conspirators from his mind, with an older memory. On the screen he is seen as a little boy, sitting in his father's office. "I'm not going to let them do it Billy. I'm not going to be ground under the wheels of big government! They're calling my sales program a pyramid scheme! But I'm going to create an underground organization that will bypass government restrictions, and garner power through terrorism and extortion! And I
won't stop with Springfield! I won't stop until my organization coils around the whole world like a giant ... Cobra!" The scene on the BrainWave Scanner changes to one of Billy seated back stage at a rally in Springfield. "War is an extension of politics and politics is an extension of economics! If the government says that an honest man can't work as much as he wants to and earn as much as he wants to -- It's wrong! And we have a right to fight back if we want to!!" The scene changes to yet another early rally. "Cobra may be small now, but we are growing every day! Soon, all of Springfield will be ours and after that... who knows what we can grow into? And next year by this time, I promise you everybody will have his own uniform!" Cobra Commander interrupts the brain wave scanner claiming this is highly classified information, and has Billy taken to the detention block while they settle on a new procedure. Storm Shadow is disgusted to think that whoever the co-conspirators are, Billy has not betrayed them. "They probably mistake his integrity for stupidity. Their type always does..."

At the PIT, the Joes leave the motor pool with an APC and VAMP on a 'local' mission. Fred observes them through binoculars. In Sierra Gordo, Stalker, Ripcord, Roadblock and Gung-Ho land in a small field, then a figure appears in the shadows of a tree ahead of them -- telling them to be quiet. In the detention block under Springfield, Storm Shadow creeps
unnoticed along the sealing pipes to Billy's cell where two guards are threatening the kid. In Fort Wadsworth the Joes leave through a secret gateway designed as a wall, rollong heavy vehicles out the front gate all the time attracts attention. Cover Girl explains to Blowtorch that they are paying a visit to a suspected undercover Cobra agent -- "Specifically the one who set up the ambush at the ARBCO brother's circus!"

Back in Sierra Gordo, the man steps out from the shadows, but the Joes don't recognise him. Three tribesmen popup behind them. In the detention block, Storm Shadow has taken care of the guards and frees Billy, but Destro blocks their escape. Back on Staten Island the Joes have arrived at an innocent looking house and move in. Suddenly bullets spray out the door knocking Lady Jaye and Duke back -- both wearing flak vests. In Sierra Gordo, Stalker realises the mysterious man is one of the Joes --
Recondo. He gets Stalker to open his sealed orders and learns that Recondo was sent in on a special mission to Sierra Gordo a week after he arrived at the PIT. Recondo explains he has been helping the local indians -- the Tucaros.

In Springfield, Storm Shadow rushes Destro with ninja speed and knocks his gun aside. The shot takes out the detention block light, and Destro calls for the guards, announcing Billy and Storm Shadow have escaped. In Staten Island, Mutt and Snake-Eyes storm the house -- as they enter the kitchen a grenade flies through the window exploding. In Sierra Gordo,
Recondo leads the Joes to a cliff top looking down to a bunker where Burkhart is being held. It is too heavily defended for their small team to assault, but Recondo has an idea. The bunker is built against the cliff on the opposite side of the small ravine. They can scale down it unnoticed and infiltrate the bunker. In Springfield the Cobra troopers search in vain for Billy and Storm Shadow who have escaped through a manhole onto the street and together they flee the town.

In Staten Island, the Crimson Twins and a Crimson Guard burst out the window on the Ferret. They fire two missiles and destroy the APC, escaping the vehicle-less Joes. Mutt and Snake-Eyes emerge from the house, with a Cobra radio and Crimson Guard suit they found in a secret basement. Duke and Lady Jaye are recovering from being shot -- though
unharmed thanks to their flak armor. Suddenly, Candy pulls up in her Balloon Bear van finding the joes on the front lawn and the house smoking. Blowtorch asks what she is doing here, and she explains... "This is my father's house... I live here!"

Commentary: "Judgments" is an interesting story, giving us an intriguing look into Cobra Commander and Billy's past.  We are given a glimpse of the Springfield rallys, Cobra Commander's Arbco office room, and little Billy's fear of his fathers aspirations for Cobra.   Storm Shadow's disgust at the co-conspirators is great to see, as in the same panel, Baroness and Major Bludd grin evilly -- caring little about what becomes of Billy.  Storm Shadow sees honor and strength in the kid and sacrifices his chance of learning the Hard Master's killer by rescuing Billy and escaping Springfield with him.  A surprising twist in the
plot, especially as this will be the herald of great changes in Storm Shadow's allegiance.

Ripcord's little chat with Gung-Ho in the snackbar about Candy is excellent.  He doesn't know whether he's cut out to be a Joe.  Somehow you know he badly wants to tell Candy the truth, and can't get his mind off her.  The mission to rescue Dr. Burkhart is exciting, as she first appeared in issue #1.  Stalker repeats his lecture from that issue, this time to Ripcord, about what they're fighting for. This will be touched upon several times throughout the series. Clarifying the Joes fight for freedom to think the way we want.  A nice little bit of depth of purpose.  Candy's connection to the Cobra safehouse is revealed, as it
belongs to her father, which will lead the Joes to wrongly suspect her. Another example of the coincidental nature of the comic, in which Candy turns out to be connected to Cobra, but stumbled across Ripcord and the others previously.

This issue features Rod Whigham as the sole artist, making a change from the passed few month's instability.  Whigham's art is not as good as it usually is, but it remains consistent throughout.  However, the coloring gives the issue a kind of tehnicolor dreamcoat feel.  I found it to use far too strong reds, yellows and blues, rather than a more realistic style tones.  It gave the issue a kind of unrealness.

Overall, this is quite a change of pace from previous issues.  Picking up from issue #33's assination plot and finally giving us the trial, after four months of suspense.  Mixing in several plots at once, rather than one as with the last couple of stories.  Several of these threads will be continued in subsequent issues.  By far the highlight has to be the flashback Billy has on the Brain Wave Scanner.  A good issue, worth getting hold of.

Reprinted in:
  • Action Force #33 & #34 (October 17th & 24th, 1987). A Marvel UK series featuring the UK's version of G.I. Joe reprints this story in three parts, alongside an original story. All references to "G.I. Joe" were changed to "Action Force".
  • G.I. JOE: Volume 4 (2002). A trade paperback collection from Marvel. Includes issues #31-41.
  • G.I. JOE: Best Worst of Cobra Commander (May 2009). A trade paperback collection from IDW, including reprints of various issues.
  • G.I. JOE: Best Worst of Storm Shadow (July 2009). A trade paperback collection from IDW, including reprints of various issues.
  • Classic G.I. JOE: Volume 4 (July 2009). A trade paperback collection from IDW Publishing. Aside from some slight changes made to the cover, this is a reprint of the earlier Marvel collection. Includes issues #31-41.